Crowds - The thread of Australian whining

Marquee
3.7K
·
5.8K
·
about 17 years

Royz wrote:

ballane wrote:

Royz wrote:

You guys have a excuse for everything on crowds. Its the fken holidays - As if kids are not aloud to got to bed late Sundays because the have a holiday on Monday????.

Really seems you along with a few others just dont get it. So what if its school holidays its not about being allowed to stay up late. Fact is its just to late for some kids. Would loved to have taken my grandaughter but she is normally in bed and asleep by 8 olclock and there is no way she would have lasted till the end of the game.

Sorry but to schedule a kids game at 7 is just crazy,yeah might be fine for some kids but there are plenty of others who just couldnt handle it being that late and to suggest otherwise really shows little understanding. 

LOL you point might add up to 3 or 4 people, But there were more kids at that home game vs Roar then there has been for some time. Its more like Adults that have issues about late times then it is about kids. Blaming late night on family matters, then actually looking at the crowds and seeing fk all teenage/adult supporters at home games makes more sense. The kids were there, The adults fans weren't.

That just confirms you dont get it or understand 3/4 shows just how out of touch you really are.
Starting XI
550
·
2.4K
·
over 14 years

ballane wrote:

Royz wrote:

ballane wrote:

Royz wrote:

You guys have a excuse for everything on crowds. Its the fken holidays - As if kids are not aloud to got to bed late Sundays because the have a holiday on Monday????.

Really seems you along with a few others just dont get it. So what if its school holidays its not about being allowed to stay up late. Fact is its just to late for some kids. Would loved to have taken my grandaughter but she is normally in bed and asleep by 8 olclock and there is no way she would have lasted till the end of the game.

Sorry but to schedule a kids game at 7 is just crazy,yeah might be fine for some kids but there are plenty of others who just couldnt handle it being that late and to suggest otherwise really shows little understanding. 

LOL you point might add up to 3 or 4 people, But there were more kids at that home game vs Roar then there has been for some time. Its more like Adults that have issues about late times then it is about kids. Blaming late night on family matters, then actually looking at the crowds and seeing fk all teenage/adult supporters at home games makes more sense. The kids were there, The adults fans weren't.

That just confirms you dont get it or understand 3/4 shows just how out of touch you really are.

So 2k of NIX's fan didn't show up because of there kids late bed times? Please like Dale you will have to do better then that.
Tegal
·
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

or even just adults who don't want to be out that late on a Sunday night. Any entertainment provider is quiet that late on a Sunday. I know that Monday's aside it is the quietest night of the week for a cinema, for example. Also many other places close early because nobody goes out. We got 7800 which is bloody good for 7pm on a Sunday, you seem to be expecting us to get 10k, which is unrealistic. 

Public transport back to the Hutt valley is also awful after the game that late on a Sunday. There is a 930 bus which people can rush for which goes to Eastbourne via queensgate. But if you don't live along that particular route (or the train route) you're screwed as there are no other connecting buses. I know of people in Tawa who don't attend for that reason. 

Having to rush back home after the game is also no fun for a lot of people. I personally hate Sunday 7pm kickoffs for that reason. 

It's a time that is less suited to a lot more people for many different reasons. Much in the same way 2am on a Monday would be even more unsuitable for a lot more people. It really isn't a hard concept to understand. 

Marquee
4.4K
·
6.8K
·
over 13 years

Royz wrote:

ballane wrote:

Royz wrote:

ballane wrote:

Royz wrote:

You guys have a excuse for everything on crowds. Its the fken holidays - As if kids are not aloud to got to bed late Sundays because the have a holiday on Monday????.

Really seems you along with a few others just dont get it. So what if its school holidays its not about being allowed to stay up late. Fact is its just to late for some kids. Would loved to have taken my grandaughter but she is normally in bed and asleep by 8 olclock and there is no way she would have lasted till the end of the game.

Sorry but to schedule a kids game at 7 is just crazy,yeah might be fine for some kids but there are plenty of others who just couldnt handle it being that late and to suggest otherwise really shows little understanding. 

LOL you point might add up to 3 or 4 people, But there were more kids at that home game vs Roar then there has been for some time. Its more like Adults that have issues about late times then it is about kids. Blaming late night on family matters, then actually looking at the crowds and seeing fk all teenage/adult supporters at home games makes more sense. The kids were there, The adults fans weren't.

That just confirms you dont get it or understand 3/4 shows just how out of touch you really are.

So 2k of NIX's fan didn't show up because of there kids late bed times? Please like Dale you will have to do better then that.

Sorry Royz but unless you have young kids yourself you are just not in a position to argue with hundreds (rather than thousands) of family poeple who need to weigh up Sunday night entertainment against a working week routine that for many starts not with a Monday morning alarm clock but with a Sunday night downtime.  

It is much easier for me now, with twenty year old children, to have a late Sunday night. I don't need to get out of bed till 7am on Mondays. When my kids were school age I would not have considered making a trip home from a football game around 9pm especially a trip of more than 30 min, as we all had to get up at 6:30am on Monday.

I am sure you are right that many supporters still decided to attend on Sunday night with young kids. However, if the game was scheduled earlier on Sunday, or on a Friday or Saturday night, we might have had 10-11K instead of just under 8K in attendance.

and 3 others
Appiah without the pace
6.6K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

Royz wrote:

So 2k of NIX's fan didn't show up because of there kids late bed times? Please like Dale you will have to do better then that.

So you aren't in Sydney? Because if you are, you have pretty good eyesight to spot who was at the game on Sunday.

Legend
3.6K
·
15K
·
about 17 years

Mainland FC wrote:

Royz wrote:

ballane wrote:

Royz wrote:

ballane wrote:

Royz wrote:

You guys have a excuse for everything on crowds. Its the fken holidays - As if kids are not aloud to got to bed late Sundays because the have a holiday on Monday????.

Really seems you along with a few others just dont get it. So what if its school holidays its not about being allowed to stay up late. Fact is its just to late for some kids. Would loved to have taken my grandaughter but she is normally in bed and asleep by 8 olclock and there is no way she would have lasted till the end of the game.

Sorry but to schedule a kids game at 7 is just crazy,yeah might be fine for some kids but there are plenty of others who just couldnt handle it being that late and to suggest otherwise really shows little understanding. 

LOL you point might add up to 3 or 4 people, But there were more kids at that home game vs Roar then there has been for some time. Its more like Adults that have issues about late times then it is about kids. Blaming late night on family matters, then actually looking at the crowds and seeing fk all teenage/adult supporters at home games makes more sense. The kids were there, The adults fans weren't.

That just confirms you dont get it or understand 3/4 shows just how out of touch you really are.

So 2k of NIX's fan didn't show up because of there kids late bed times? Please like Dale you will have to do better then that.

Sorry Royz but unless you have young kids yourself you are just not in a position to argue with hundreds (rather than thousands) of family poeple who need to weigh up Sunday night entertainment against a working week routine that for many starts not with a Monday morning alarm clock but with a Sunday night downtime.  

It is much easier for me now, with twenty year old children, to have a late Sunday night. I don't need to get out of bed till 7am on Mondays. When my kids were school age I would not have considered making a trip home from a football game around 9pm especially a trip of more than 30 min, as we all had to get up at 6:30am on Monday.

I am sure you are right that many supporters still decided to attend on Sunday night with young kids. However, if the game was scheduled earlier on Sunday, or on a Friday or Saturday night, we might have had 10-11K instead of just under 8K in attendance.

So this. 

Good example: one of mine would be fine for a late game - she would take it like a champ, be fully into it, then crash out big time in the car on the way home, no problems. However another one of mine would be an absolute nightmare. She gets to that over-tired point and just goes into full meltdown mode, kicking and screaming, just nuts about every little thing "NO DAD I said put my chips and lemonade on THIS side of my seat!" - which then turns into a lecture from me about talking nicely to people, which turns into a worse meltdown and an automatic 'time-out' (not possible at the stadium), and usually doesn't resolve itself completely until she actually goes to bed. I would never dream of taking that one to a game that finishes after 7pm. 

Jag
Not Elite enough
730
·
8K
·
almost 17 years

Anyone know just how many games in Aus have had 7 pm kick-offs (local time) on a Sunday night, and what the effect on crowds has been? Any Aussie I've spoken to on the subject has been of the opinion that it's complete lunacy to have A League games kicking off at 7 on a Sunday.

And, for the record, I wouldn't take my little fella to the game at Eden Park on a SATURDAY night because the kick-off time was 7.15. Kids, eh!

The better Barnes
210
·
360
·
over 12 years

Royz wrote:

You guys have a excuse for everything on crowds. Its the fken holidays - As if kids are not aloud to got to bed late Sundays because the have a holiday on Monday????.

Why not compare to the Melbourne City crowd the night before. In a city of 3.6 million more people, with a team at the top of the table, playing brilliant football and scoring plenty of goals (was 10 more than the next top scorer, now 13), against another top team in WSW, and having arguably the best striker and best midfielder in the league, with a much more attractive time slot (Saturday night vs Sunday night), they only managed to get 2k more to their game.
First Team Squad
500
·
1.9K
·
about 17 years

I guess I would just be interested to find out when the perfect time for a game is. You go to the start of this thread and plenty complained when all our games were 5pm on Sunday.

Appiah without the pace
6.6K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

Dome has consistently said they prefer 3pm games. But know they won't get them.

Tegal
·
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

Ryan54 wrote:

I guess I would just be interested to find out when the perfect time for a game is. You go to the start of this thread and plenty complained when all our games were 5pm on Sunday.

I think that was actually the best time. I did some figures a while back (less games then, so data was a bit patchy). Maybe someone could dig that thread out. Been thinking about updating it now that the discussion has come up again. 

Marquee
7.2K
·
9.4K
·
over 13 years

People are doing stuff during the day on the weekend. I wouldn't have thought that 3pm is a good time, especially if kids are playing cricket, people are having bbq's, going to the beach, etc.

Marquee
2.1K
·
6.4K
·
over 14 years

Ryan wrote:

People are doing stuff during the day on the weekend. I wouldn't have thought that 3pm is a good time, especially if kids are playing cricket, people are having bbq's, going to the beach, etc.

we will never ever ever ever get a 3pm kick off. Never. Not now not in 10 years . It will not happen. Crowds in the stadium, aside from providing  atmosphere mean nothing in the overall scheme of things. It is TV audience that matters and like it or not the money from TV is what keeps game going.  Talk of a 3pm kick off is a waste of oxygen
Tegal
·
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

that's a bit simplistic as no clubs (including owners and fans) = no tv deal. So they do have to give a little in terms of kickoff times. But for the most part, yes TV will always get a large say in kickoff times. I don't think 7pm Sunday finds that balance between give and take, it's such an awful time to impose on a club (and its fans). 

First Team Squad
280
·
1.6K
·
about 12 years

Tegal wrote:

I don't think 7pm Sunday finds that balance between give and take, it's such an awful time to impose on a club (and its fans). 

petal

Marquee
2.1K
·
6.4K
·
over 14 years

Tegal wrote:

that's a bit simplistic as no clubs (including owners and fans) = no tv deal. So they do have to give a little in terms of kickoff times. But for the most part, yes TV will always get a large say in kickoff times. I don't think 7pm Sunday finds that balance between give and take, it's such an awful time to impose on a club (and its fans). 

Yup and thankfully we have only a couple this year with Fox using Aussie games for that 5.00pm Eastern time kick off
Marquee
7.2K
·
9.4K
·
over 13 years

sthn.jeff wrote:

Ryan wrote:

People are doing stuff during the day on the weekend. I wouldn't have thought that 3pm is a good time, especially if kids are playing cricket, people are having bbq's, going to the beach, etc.

we will never ever ever ever get a 3pm kick off. Never. Not now not in 10 years . It will not happen. Crowds in the stadium, aside from providing  atmosphere mean nothing in the overall scheme of things. It is TV audience that matters and like it or not the money from TV is what keeps game going.  Talk of a 3pm kick off is a waste of oxygen

if our nz tv deal was higher then we would have more say on kick off times. Never say never.
Tegal
·
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

yellowsite wrote:

Tegal wrote:

I don't think 7pm Sunday finds that balance between give and take, it's such an awful time to impose on a club (and its fans). 

petal

I turned up. But whatever. Go ahead and say people should turn up no matter what the time if it makes you feel like a superior fan. 

If 2am NZT was a better time for tv would you still be saying "petal"? Because if you accept that is a bad time, then you should also accept that 7pm Sunday is a bad time for a lot of people too. 

Tegal
·
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

sthn.jeff wrote:

Tegal wrote:

that's a bit simplistic as no clubs (including owners and fans) = no tv deal. So they do have to give a little in terms of kickoff times. But for the most part, yes TV will always get a large say in kickoff times. I don't think 7pm Sunday finds that balance between give and take, it's such an awful time to impose on a club (and its fans). 

Yup and thankfully we have only a couple this year with Fox using Aussie games for that 5.00pm Eastern time kick off

Yep and I think that is an example of a bit of give on fox/FFAs part in accepting that 7pm sunday is a bad kickoff time to burden the Phoenix with. Give and take. 

First Team Squad
280
·
1.6K
·
about 12 years

Tegal wrote:

yellowsite wrote:

Tegal wrote:

I don't think 7pm Sunday finds that balance between give and take, it's such an awful time to impose on a club (and its fans). 

petal

I turned up. But whatever. Go ahead and say people should turn up no matter what the time if it makes you feel like a superior fan. 

If 2am NZT was a better time for tv would you still be saying "petal"? Because if you accept that is a bad time, then you should also accept that 7pm Sunday is a bad time for a lot of people too. 

There are sacrifices being in a Aus comp. There are two games at this time, that's not a lot.

There's generally only one game on a Sunday so execs would want it on primetime, or closest to.

Marquee
2.1K
·
6.4K
·
over 14 years

Ryan wrote:

sthn.jeff wrote:

Ryan wrote:

People are doing stuff during the day on the weekend. I wouldn't have thought that 3pm is a good time, especially if kids are playing cricket, people are having bbq's, going to the beach, etc.

we will never ever ever ever get a 3pm kick off. Never. Not now not in 10 years . It will not happen. Crowds in the stadium, aside from providing  atmosphere mean nothing in the overall scheme of things. It is TV audience that matters and like it or not the money from TV is what keeps game going.  Talk of a 3pm kick off is a waste of oxygen

if our nz tv deal was higher then we would have more say on kick off times. Never say never.

But 7pm suits TV in NZ, more so than 5pm.  So yes I will say never
Starting XI
4.1K
·
3.7K
·
about 10 years

Ryan54 wrote:

I guess I would just be interested to find out when the perfect time for a game is. You go to the start of this thread and plenty complained when all our games were 5pm on Sunday.

The perfect time for a game is 7-7:30PM on a Friday or Saturday night.

Its accepted you have to get lumped with a few Sunday's etc.  And that's fine but last year we seemed to have way more than average, hence the bitching.

For the kids game to promote families through the gate though 3PM on a Sunday seems fine.  

Tegal
·
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

interestingly when I last checked our Friday night games were amongst the worst attended kickoff times. 

Starting XI
4.1K
·
3.7K
·
about 10 years

Tegal wrote:

interestingly when I last checked our Friday night games were amongst the worst attended kickoff times. 

Oh really? Shark.  I thought those were the best, but maybe I was just drunker.

Marquee
2.1K
·
6.4K
·
over 14 years

Tegal wrote:

interestingly when I last checked our Friday night games were amongst the worst attended kickoff times. 

Take your facts elsewhere hombre. Facts have no place in this forum.
Tegal
·
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

hoping I'm not wrong about that, but do remember it surprising me. Turns out I did attendance based on month in relation to last result rather than kickoff time. Am sure someone did it though, 2ndbest maybe?

Jag
Not Elite enough
730
·
8K
·
almost 17 years

sthn.jeff wrote:

Tegal wrote:

interestingly when I last checked our Friday night games were amongst the worst attended kickoff times. 

Take your facts elsewhere hombre. Facts have no place in this forum.

This. I don't come in here to read facts. This place is built on conspiracy theories, ridiculous rumours and complete idiocy. It's what we rely on.

Facts? Not even once!

Legend
3.6K
·
15K
·
about 17 years

I understand the argument "there's an excuse for every timeslot" to some degree but it does seem there is a consensus that Sundays at 7pm is a bit sh*t. 

For kids it has to be a 3pm or 5pm kick-off surely, on a saturday or sunday.

As for the rest of the games, personally I always enjoyed the 7 or 7.30pm kickoffs on a Friday or Saturday night. Especially Friday - everyone's a bit merrier having been on the lash since work finished - when I used to hang in the zone the chanting would be noticeably louder on friday nights...

Appiah without the pace
6.6K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

Tegal wrote:

hoping I'm not wrong about that, but do remember it surprising me. Turns out I did attendance based on month in relation to last result rather than kickoff time. Am sure someone did it though, 2ndbest maybe?

yeah I got that. Need to catch up on last 6 months though.

Appiah without the pace
6.6K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

Drunk_Monk wrote:

Tegal wrote:

interestingly when I last checked our Friday night games were amongst the worst attended kickoff times. 

Oh really? Shark.  I thought those were the best, but maybe I was just drunker.

over 50% of Nix's crowds are families. So if you assume that most non-families have more flexibility over when they can attend, you can see why the Nix want family friendly times. Helps to build a next generation of fan too.

Marquee
5.3K
·
9.5K
·
over 12 years

Sunday 7pm is just not ideal for any segment of the local market, despite it being a good time for TV. Fridays and Saturdays at 7pm might suck for families too but at least they suit some people - those who want to drink and get raucous. Sunday afternoons suit families but not the drinking raucous types as much. Sunday evenings suck for everyone

Surge
·
Can I have some lungs please miss
1.1K
·
7.5K
·
over 16 years

Sunday afternoons suit families but not the drinking raucous types as much. Sunday evenings suck for everyone

Except Fox Sport (aka: the paymasters).
Marquee
4.4K
·
6.8K
·
over 13 years

Sunday 7pm is just not ideal for any segment of the local market, despite it being a good time for TV. Fridays and Saturdays at 7pm might suck for families too but at least they suit some people - those who want to drink and get raucous. Sunday afternoons suit families but not the drinking raucous types as much. Sunday evenings suck for everyone

I still remember the game Phoenix played on a Sunday night, away in Perth. I doubt SKY got many viewers in New Zealand for a game that finished well after midnight on Monday morning.

Marquee
420
·
6.3K
·
almost 17 years

so what time can they play at where it won't be an excuse again? genuine question

Tegal
·
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

Cosimo wrote:

so what time can they play at where it won't be an excuse again? genuine question

There will always be excuses for different people at different times. Likewise, some times will suit some people and won't be any good for others. For example, During the day on a weekday would work better for me as then I wouldn't need to take a night off work to attend on a weekend, but then most people wouldn't be able to attend because they'd be at work. 

It's not about making excuses to not attend games, it's appreciating the fact that people have lives outside of the Phoenix, and certain kickoff times are clearly inconvenient for a majority of those people, resulting in lower crowds. 

As people said above, Saturday 7pm is inconvenient for some families (though not as many because it's not a school night unlike Sunday) but really suits those looking to make a big night out of it. 7pm on Sunday is bad for a wider range of people. It's not an all or nothing proposition. 

At the end of the day, we still got 7800 which considering the kickoff time and all the factors working against us having any sort of crowd, was a very impressive effort. I was expecting 6000. 

You can also then take a wider approach to looking at the figure (As Kyle did earlier) and compare the crowd/s to the rest of the league. Where we do very well considering the 'lesser' kickoff times we get lumped with, our smaller population, lack of derbies etc. we are 2nd in attendance per capita. 

Listen here Fudgeface
3.7K
·
15K
·
about 14 years

We are still arguing over whether it was a decent crowd or not? Bloody hell.

Marquee
3.7K
·
5.8K
·
about 17 years

As a matter of interest is anyone aware if any of the clubs in Aussie have a 7pm kickoff on a Sunday as a regular time slot. Yes im aware 7 here is mostly 5 or earlier over there.Im aware they use it on a Friday and Saturday but think Perth might be the only ones who have used it on a Sunday.

Marquee
5.3K
·
9.5K
·
over 12 years

SurgeQld wrote:

Sunday afternoons suit families but not the drinking raucous types as much. Sunday evenings suck for everyone

Except Fox Sport (aka: the paymasters).

I did say it was a good time for TV in the first sentence of my post
First Team Squad
500
·
1.9K
·
about 17 years

ballane wrote:

As a matter of interest is anyone aware if any of the clubs in Aussie have a 7pm kickoff on a Sunday as a regular time slot. Yes im aware 7 here is mostly 5 or earlier over there.Im aware they use it on a Friday and Saturday but think Perth might be the only ones who have used it on a Sunday.

They generally have Perth play at 5pm on Sunday, which is 7pm eastern. So generally no games at 7 on the east coast.

Life and death
2.4K
·
5.5K
·
about 17 years

If you are holding a special promotion to attract Mormons, you don't hold that promotion on a Sunday do you? Likewise if you holf a promotion for kids, it needs to be at a time that suits kids [or the parents that would be bringing them]

You’ll need an account to join the conversation!

Sign in Sign up