Elimination Final v Melbourne City | Sunday 3rd May | 7:00pm

First Team Squad
280
·
1.6K
·
almost 12 years
Marquee
5.3K
·
9.5K
·
over 12 years

I reckon Broich could play the regista role of you put him in there, he's definitely got the skills and vision for it, would just be a matter of adjusting to playing deeper

Marquee
1.3K
·
5.3K
·
over 16 years

I reckon Broich could play the regista role of you put him in there, he's definitely got the skills and vision for it, would just be a matter of adjusting to playing deeper

He is at times played in CM but is normally paired with a more defensive player so can get forward. Brattan is their playmaker from the base of midfield and Portaloo before him. They are there just not as good as top players in Europe, obvious much.

Legend
7.2K
·
14K
·
over 16 years

Oska wrote:

martinb wrote:

Oska wrote:

Totally disagree. Riera is very similar to Carrick in my opinion. Positions himself well, usually avoids having to put in a tough challenge and keeps the ball moving, including getting attacks started. Lia has good lateral passing but is no where near as incisive as Riera. In terms of passing ability I think Smith, Hernandez, Sanchez, Bonevacia and Ifill are all examples of players we've had more like Pirlo than Lia.

Don't watch Carrick or Pirlo enough I guess. Or Xabi Alonso. I'll watch the last few games of the EPL closely.

I agree all the players you mention have a greater range of passing- however not many of them have played a deep lying playmaker role, they mostly played advanced roles.

Does Pirlo/Carrick buzz around as much as Riera does? 

Like CT said, no one in the league really plays a deep lying playmaker role, certainly not Lia. I wouldn't say Riera "buzzes" around, typically stays quite deep and central, much like the (much more accomplished) players mentioned above. He certainly can't ping it around like a Pirlo or Alonso, but the more I think about it the more I feel Carrick (or Daley Blind) is a very good comparison.

Yeh, I certainly watched Blind a bit at the start of the season, when I might have been going to play in the mids more often. Just keeps the ball moving yeh? Safe secure options. 

First Team Squad
280
·
1.6K
·
almost 12 years
Marquee
1.2K
·
8.2K
·
almost 17 years

martinb wrote:

Oska wrote:

martinb wrote:

Oska wrote:

Totally disagree. Riera is very similar to Carrick in my opinion. Positions himself well, usually avoids having to put in a tough challenge and keeps the ball moving, including getting attacks started. Lia has good lateral passing but is no where near as incisive as Riera. In terms of passing ability I think Smith, Hernandez, Sanchez, Bonevacia and Ifill are all examples of players we've had more like Pirlo than Lia.

Don't watch Carrick or Pirlo enough I guess. Or Xabi Alonso. I'll watch the last few games of the EPL closely.

I agree all the players you mention have a greater range of passing- however not many of them have played a deep lying playmaker role, they mostly played advanced roles.

Does Pirlo/Carrick buzz around as much as Riera does? 

Like CT said, no one in the league really plays a deep lying playmaker role, certainly not Lia. I wouldn't say Riera "buzzes" around, typically stays quite deep and central, much like the (much more accomplished) players mentioned above. He certainly can't ping it around like a Pirlo or Alonso, but the more I think about it the more I feel Carrick (or Daley Blind) is a very good comparison.

Yeh, I certainly watched Blind a bit at the start of the season, when I might have been going to play in the mids more often. Just keeps the ball moving yeh? Safe secure options. 

Yeah, I can see A-Rod long term dropping deeper and doing that for us once Riera's done, if he sticks around.
Tegal
·
Head Sleuth
3K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

That actually wasn't bad. It was the radio sport guys that were negative as hell in their questioning. But then we did just come off a bad run of results. 

valeo
·
Legend
4.6K
·
18K
·
about 17 years

Better than Harper's last interview I guess.

Legend
7.2K
·
14K
·
over 16 years

Oska wrote:

martinb wrote:

Oska wrote:

martinb wrote:

Oska wrote:

Totally disagree. Riera is very similar to Carrick in my opinion. Positions himself well, usually avoids having to put in a tough challenge and keeps the ball moving, including getting attacks started. Lia has good lateral passing but is no where near as incisive as Riera. In terms of passing ability I think Smith, Hernandez, Sanchez, Bonevacia and Ifill are all examples of players we've had more like Pirlo than Lia.

Don't watch Carrick or Pirlo enough I guess. Or Xabi Alonso. I'll watch the last few games of the EPL closely.

I agree all the players you mention have a greater range of passing- however not many of them have played a deep lying playmaker role, they mostly played advanced roles.

Does Pirlo/Carrick buzz around as much as Riera does? 

Like CT said, no one in the league really plays a deep lying playmaker role, certainly not Lia. I wouldn't say Riera "buzzes" around, typically stays quite deep and central, much like the (much more accomplished) players mentioned above. He certainly can't ping it around like a Pirlo or Alonso, but the more I think about it the more I feel Carrick (or Daley Blind) is a very good comparison.

Yeh, I certainly watched Blind a bit at the start of the season, when I might have been going to play in the mids more often. Just keeps the ball moving yeh? Safe secure options. 

Yeah, I can see A-Rod long term dropping deeper and doing that for us once Riera's done, if he sticks around.

I'd like to see him playing further forward and being dynamic the way he was against West Ham. 

I wouldn't mind seeing an experiment with Roly further back and A-Rod further forward...Not quite sure how we'd fit them all in though

Surge
·
Can I have some lungs please miss
1.1K
·
7.5K
·
over 16 years

martinb wrote:

I wouldn't mind seeing an experiment with Roly further back and A-Rod further forward...Not quite sure how we'd fit them all in though

I was thinking this the other day... when we signed them wasn't Roly a DM and A-Rod a b2b CM who liked to get forward? It's as though Ernie has swapped them.
Starting XI
430
·
2.6K
·
over 16 years

What the... ??? Is that the same Andy Harper from a couple of weeks ago? Or did someone put something into his morning coffee?

Chant Savant
2.5K
·
12K
·
almost 17 years

I dislike Andy Harper a lot

Phoenix Academy
110
·
470
·
about 13 years

SurgeQld wrote:

martinb wrote:

I wouldn't mind seeing an experiment with Roly further back and A-Rod further forward...Not quite sure how we'd fit them all in though

I was thinking this the other day... when we signed them wasn't Roly a DM and A-Rod a b2b CM who liked to get forward? It's as though Ernie has swapped them.

I really like how Roly plays further forward.  His first touch is usually pretty good and he manages to get a turn in in some pretty tight spots.  Would much rather see him doing this in the opposition half rather than ours.

Legend
7.2K
·
14K
·
over 16 years

Rosco wrote:

SurgeQld wrote:

martinb wrote:

I wouldn't mind seeing an experiment with Roly further back and A-Rod further forward...Not quite sure how we'd fit them all in though

I was thinking this the other day... when we signed them wasn't Roly a DM and A-Rod a b2b CM who liked to get forward? It's as though Ernie has swapped them.

I really like how Roly plays further forward.  His first touch is usually pretty good and he manages to get a turn in in some pretty tight spots.  Would much rather see him doing this in the opposition half rather than ours.

Yep, but I don't mind A-Rod doing this either.  

Wouldn't hurt to have one or two variations up our sleeve, just in case we go on, say, a run where we can't score a goal for love or money...

Elimination Final v Melbourne City | Sunday 3rd May | 7:00pm

You’ll need an account to join the conversation!

Sign in Sign up