Sarpreet Singh (FC Hansa Rostock | Germany)

WeeNix
170
·
550
·
about 11 years

1860 are my life....one day.....finally back where they belong.....winning the bundesliga team.....one day when I am 73 years old 

Groundskeeper Willie
700
·
7.5K
·
about 16 years

I read in a live updates thread that he had a shot saved late in the game. Shame it didn’t make the highlights but maybe it wasn’t threatening enough to make the cut.

Groundskeeper Willie
700
·
7.5K
·
about 16 years

Good minutes anyway

Marquee
5.3K
·
9.5K
·
over 12 years

Bayern have sold Renato Sanches to Lille, so that's one less midfielder on their books (although he plays in a deeper role than Singh)

Starting XI
6.9K
·
4.7K
·
almost 10 years

Both the first team and reserves have matches on the same day (only a few hours apart too) for 4 out of the next 5 matchdays. So won't be as easy for him to be named in the first team and then look to play for the reserves the day after. Take into account the transfer dealings they've made lately as well and unfortunately he gets bumped down the pecking order. 

Tom Doyle's Chemnitzer up next, then Stefan Marinovic's former club Unterhaching, and then Ingolstadt who briefly graced the Bundesliga a couple of seasons back, up after the International break. So it's not like he won't be having a bloody interesting time over there.

Starting XI
3K
·
3.1K
·
almost 7 years

Singh with the start for Bayern II against Chemnitzer, kicking off in an hour. No word yet if Doyle's playing a part for them tonight

Starting XI
6.9K
·
4.7K
·
almost 10 years

mrsmiis wrote:

Singh with the start for Bayern II against Chemnitzer, kicking off in an hour. No word yet if Doyle's playing a part for them tonight

Doyle back on the bench today for Chemnitzer. 

Starting XI
3K
·
3.1K
·
almost 7 years

54th minute, Singh provides a really nice assist to Dajaku to equalise 1-1 just after having a shot saved: https://streamable.com/ujne1

Been seriously brilliant tonight - pretty surprised to see that he easily looks the best player on the pitch. Playing as sort of a raumdeuter on the right wing, shows that Bayern may be treating him as a Muller protege

Starting XI
3K
·
3.1K
·
almost 7 years

2-2 it ends, no Doyle. Singh MOTM, he was incredible - wonder how much of his success is down to having two years already as a pro, other members of his team looked out of their depth. Would say A-League was higher quality

Legend
11K
·
22K
·
almost 9 years

Finishes 2-2, Doyle an unused sub for Chemnitzer, who remain 2nd last (19th) on the table.

Bayern II up to 13th.

Starting XI
2.4K
·
3.1K
·
over 11 years

mrsmiis wrote:

54th minute, Singh provides a really nice assist to Dajaku to equalise 1-1 just after having a shot saved: https://streamable.com/ujne1

Been seriously brilliant tonight - pretty surprised to see that he easily looks the best player on the pitch. Playing as sort of a raumdeuter on the right wing, shows that Bayern may be treating him as a Muller protege

What a great assist!

Marquee
1.2K
·
8.2K
·
almost 17 years

Seems strange that he's been moved up to #28 for the first team but is in #31 for the reserves.

Starting XI
2.1K
·
4.8K
·
almost 17 years

mrsmiis wrote:

2-2 it ends, no Doyle. Singh MOTM, he was incredible - wonder how much of his success is down to having two years already as a pro, other members of his team looked out of their depth. Would say A-League was higher quality

You seem surprised. 

Quality is known to be a bit suspect at that level in Germany. 

It's only really England that has depth/quality outside of the top two divisions which is why reserve teams are banned unlike Germany, Spain etc.

Lawyerish
1.8K
·
4.8K
·
over 13 years

I suspect there are other reasons why they are banned as well

It should be noted we have just paid what is meant to be our first transfer fee for a player from the third division in Italy 

Starting XI
2.1K
·
4.8K
·
almost 17 years

I suspect there are other reasons why they are banned as well

It should be noted we have just paid what is meant to be our first transfer fee for a player from the third division in Italy 

True but like Singh has bucket loads of potential and is young. Would be a different story if he was 30.

Starting XI
3K
·
3.1K
·
almost 7 years

Singh on the bench for the first team again in a fan-day friendly against Vilshofen, who have a 61y/o Klaus Augenthaler in defense (1990 WC winner).

Marquee
1.3K
·
5.3K
·
over 16 years

Looks like Singh starts the 2nd half on the left side of a midfield 3.

Phoenix Academy
270
·
460
·
over 9 years

Marto wrote:

mrsmiis wrote:

2-2 it ends, no Doyle. Singh MOTM, he was incredible - wonder how much of his success is down to having two years already as a pro, other members of his team looked out of their depth. Would say A-League was higher quality

You seem surprised. 

Quality is known to be a bit suspect at that level in Germany. 

It's only really England that has depth/quality outside of the top two divisions which is why reserve teams are banned unlike Germany, Spain etc.

This is why some Bundesliga Clubs (eg Bayer Leverkusen, Eintracht Frankfurt) made the decision a few year ago not to have B/u23 teams as they'd rather loan their best young players to Bundesliga 1/2 rather than have them play level 3/4.

(Their next team beneath the Bundesliga level is u19, most of whom will be released - eg Leverkusen offered pro contracts to 2 ex u19 squad players last year). 

Marquee
5.3K
·
9.5K
·
over 12 years

Marto wrote:

mrsmiis wrote:

2-2 it ends, no Doyle. Singh MOTM, he was incredible - wonder how much of his success is down to having two years already as a pro, other members of his team looked out of their depth. Would say A-League was higher quality

You seem surprised. 

Quality is known to be a bit suspect at that level in Germany. 

It's only really England that has depth/quality outside of the top two divisions which is why reserve teams are banned unlike Germany, Spain etc.

Is the English third tier better than the A League these days though? Maybe the top teams but for instance Keogh came from the Championship to the A League, Mooy went the other way and got promoted. Those are top level A League players,  but still I don't think that the A League quality is as bad globally as most people think.

We will see how Ball goes for us I guess...

Woof Woof
2.7K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

Marto wrote:

mrsmiis wrote:

2-2 it ends, no Doyle. Singh MOTM, he was incredible - wonder how much of his success is down to having two years already as a pro, other members of his team looked out of their depth. Would say A-League was higher quality

You seem surprised. 

Quality is known to be a bit suspect at that level in Germany. 

It's only really England that has depth/quality outside of the top two divisions which is why reserve teams are banned unlike Germany, Spain etc.

Is the English third tier better than the A League these days though? Maybe the top teams but for instance Keogh came from the Championship to the A League, Mooy went the other way and got promoted. Those are top level A League players,  but still I don't think that the A League quality is as bad globally as most people think.

We will see how Ball goes for us I guess...

League 1 is very average. I don't think that there is third tier anywhere in the world that's better than the A-league, although obviously in some of those leagues there are big clubs that have fallen on hard times, and players who will go on to bigger and better things.

Starting XI
3K
·
3.1K
·
almost 7 years

and in the midst of all this, Singh scored again in a 13-1 win. Though they were playing against guys that a YF team would challenge (hence the 61 year old Augenthaler in defense) so Bayern weren’t trying at all

Yeah League One’s a bit large to compare the whole thing to the A-League, same with the Championship. Look at a team like Rotherham, relegated from the second tier last year, and most A-League teams would take care of them imo.

Comparing to Germany’s 3. Liga though - we have Yeboah who was an average rotation piece over there and is an average rotation piece here, and Singh who was great here and is shaping up to be brilliant there. Overall reckon the A-League's better but this is skewed by the quality gap between Aussie/NZers and imports, hence my surprise that a Kiwi heads over and instantly 'tears up' the league

Legend
11K
·
22K
·
almost 9 years

Stevie Taylor said on the pod recently, that he would place A league at level of, lower Championship or upper League One sides.

Marquee
1.3K
·
5.3K
·
over 16 years

mrsmiis wrote:

and in the midst of all this, Singh scored again in a 13-1 win. Though they were playing against guys that a YF team would challenge (hence the 61 year old Augenthaler in defense) so Bayern weren’t trying at all

Yeah League One’s a bit large to compare the whole thing to the A-League, same with the Championship. Look at a team like Rotherham, relegated from the second tier last year, and most A-League teams would take care of them imo.

Comparing to Germany’s 3. Liga though - we have Yeboah who was an average rotation piece over there and is an average rotation piece here, and Singh who was great here and is shaping up to be brilliant there. Overall reckon the A-League's better but this is skewed by the quality gap between Aussie/NZers and imports, hence my surprise that a Kiwi heads over and instantly 'tears up' the league

Augenthaler didn't play the whole game, wasn't on the field when I started watching midway through the first half and kitted up for Bayern in the 2nd half. Didn't see if he came on. Its basically a game in his honour, played at the stadium named after him.

Chemintzer are very poor, they have no money (and dodgy fan base) - not indicative of the quality across the league. It probably is more variable in quality, teams at the top would be close in quality to the bottom third of the 2nd BDL and teams in the bottom third close to top teams in the regional leagues. One big team in there is FCK, 50k seat stadium, and 2 times BDL and Pokal winners (both in the 90's), and quite a few teams that have been in the top division in the past 30 years.

Woof Woof
2.7K
·
19K
·
almost 17 years

1860 Munich is another huge club currently in 3. Bundesliga. There's also a few clubs that were regulars in the old DDR top division Oberliga, some of whom were quite successful in that era. Magdeburg won the Cup Winners' Cup in the 1970s for example.

Legend
11K
·
22K
·
almost 9 years

FCK (FC Kaiserlautern) also won two German titles in 1950s. So total of 4 league championships. Yes a big club in Liga 3 (first time ever dropped to the 3rd tier).

Marquee
1.3K
·
5.3K
·
over 16 years

coochiee wrote:

FCK (FC Kaiserlautern) also won two German titles in 1950s. So total of 4 league championships. Yes a big club in Liga 3 (first time ever dropped to the 3rd tier).

German titles before 1963 are a little different. There was no national league, you had many regional leagues that were all amateur with the winners of the regional leagues playing in a knock out comp to see who was German Champion.
Trialist
7
·
86
·
about 17 years
Starting XI
2.1K
·
4.8K
·
almost 17 years

coochiee wrote:

Stevie Taylor said on the pod recently, that he would place A league at level of, lower Championship or upper League One sides.

As someone who attends League one/two games 2/3 times a month and follows the Nix religiously I'd say A League is mid League One.

Marquee
970
·
6.5K
·
over 11 years

Marto wrote:

coochiee wrote:

Stevie Taylor said on the pod recently, that he would place A league at level of, lower Championship or upper League One sides.

As someone who attends League one/two games 2/3 times a month and follows the Nix religiously I'd say A League is mid League One.

10 Peterborough

11 Burton Albion

12 Bristol Rovers

Starting XI
3K
·
3.1K
·
almost 7 years

Bullion wrote:

mrsmiis wrote:

and in the midst of all this, Singh scored again in a 13-1 win. Though they were playing against guys that a YF team would challenge (hence the 61 year old Augenthaler in defense) so Bayern weren’t trying at all

Yeah League One’s a bit large to compare the whole thing to the A-League, same with the Championship. Look at a team like Rotherham, relegated from the second tier last year, and most A-League teams would take care of them imo.

Comparing to Germany’s 3. Liga though - we have Yeboah who was an average rotation piece over there and is an average rotation piece here, and Singh who was great here and is shaping up to be brilliant there. Overall reckon the A-League's better but this is skewed by the quality gap between Aussie/NZers and imports, hence my surprise that a Kiwi heads over and instantly 'tears up' the league

Augenthaler didn't play the whole game, wasn't on the field when I started watching midway through the first half and kitted up for Bayern in the 2nd half. Didn't see if he came on. Its basically a game in his honour, played at the stadium named after him.

Yeah started for Vilshofen but was subbed off probbaly halfway through the first half, came on for Bayern in the 78th minute

Marquee
2.1K
·
8.2K
·
about 17 years

Marto wrote:

coochiee wrote:

Stevie Taylor said on the pod recently, that he would place A league at level of, lower Championship or upper League One sides.

As someone who attends League one/two games 2/3 times a month and follows the Nix religiously I'd say A League is mid League One.

There is more variety in the quality of players in the A-League.  Best players are very good, worst players in a match day squad are pretty weak.  So it makes comparisons hard.  

Opinion Privileges revoked
4.6K
·
9.8K
·
over 14 years

Yeah, there are very many more "levels" in English than in Australasian football. To some degree the latter reminds me of the local Gaelic football scene, where people who just rock up to a club one day and have never played before might be training next to a guy who won an All-Ireland Championship medal.

Starting XI
3K
·
3.1K
·
almost 7 years

Singh starting for Bayern II against Marinović’s old club Unterhaching. Being streamed live on Youtube

https://youtu.be/Cg1Ufzjv-Po

Bayern’s first team play Mainz in like 2 hours

Starting XI
3K
·
3.1K
·
almost 7 years

And he scores a beautiful goal! Lobs the keeper from the edge of the box on the volley to make it 1-1, 39th minute. Really nice assist too

https://twitter.com/mrsmiis/status/1167789844996608000?s=21

First Team Squad
1.2K
·
1.6K
·
over 14 years

mrsmiis wrote:

Singh starting for Bayern II against Marinović’s old club Unterhaching. Being streamed live on Youtube

https://youtu.be/Cg1Ufzjv-Po

Bayern’s first team play Mainz in like 2 hours

I only watched from the 75th minute onwards, but that was legitimately terrible. I can't see how Singh is supposed to develop further playing at that level. Bayern II had at least 4 players who were completely useless (contributing literally almost nothing to the game) over the 15 minutes I watched.

Life and death
2.4K
·
5.5K
·
about 17 years

lucky he’s not just playing at that level then

First Team Squad
520
·
1K
·
over 10 years

Hoepfully a loan can come soon

First Team Squad
1.2K
·
1.6K
·
over 14 years

lucky he’s not just playing at that level then

What other level is he playing at right now?

Marquee
5.3K
·
9.5K
·
over 12 years

djtim3000 wrote:

lucky he’s not just playing at that level then

What other level is he playing at right now?

An international against Lithuania soon?
WeeNix
390
·
910
·
about 11 years

djtim3000 wrote:

mrsmiis wrote:

Singh starting for Bayern II against Marinović’s old club Unterhaching. Being streamed live on Youtube

https://youtu.be/Cg1Ufzjv-Po

Bayern’s first team play Mainz in like 2 hours

I only watched from the 75th minute onwards, but that was legitimately terrible. I can't see how Singh is supposed to develop further playing at that level. Bayern II had at least 4 players who were completely useless (contributing literally almost nothing to the game) over the 15 minutes I watched.

Yeah have to.be completely useless to be on the books at Bayern... 

You’ll need an account to join the conversation!

Sign in Sign up