Legend
3.6K
·
15K
·
almost 17 years

Ok, so ronniemac calculated the scenario if Brumbys, Youngheart and Buffon are all removed from the team standings, and it looks like this;

Compared to the actual standings, with those 3 still in it;

Bit of a difference there. Arsenal and ManU both boosted fairly substantially.

How do people feel about this? Is it really fair?

The alternative is we leave them in, but they will log 0's for the remainder, so ManU and Arsenal will slowly slip into oblivion.

Would run a poll if I could. Perhaps when you make your next pics, give your opinion on this at the same time?

First Team Squad
1K
·
1.7K
·
over 15 years

Norwich 2 - 2 Leicester

Pukki, Cantwell

Bournemouth 1 - 2 Chelsea

Tammy, Pulisic

Watford 2 - 3 Liverpool

Firmino, Salah

Everton 0 - 2 ManU

Bruno, Martial

On players leaving: neither situation is fair. If there was money riding on it, I'd say the players that have left should all be given 0s for the rest of the season. Given the team part is a "fun" event, then remove the players who said they cannot play.

Starting XI
480
·
4.1K
·
over 14 years

paulm wrote:

Ok, so ronniemac calculated the scenario if Brumbys, Youngheart and Buffon are all removed from the team standings, and it looks like this;

Compared to the actual standings, with those 3 still in it;

Bit of a difference there. Arsenal and ManU both boosted fairly substantially.

How do people feel about this? Is it really fair?

The alternative is we leave them in, but they will log 0's for the remainder, so ManU and Arsenal will slowly slip into oblivion.

Would run a poll if I could. Perhaps when you make your next pics, give your opinion on this at the same time?

Could you work out what their average is for the picks they made until they stopped picking and use that to calculate it?

so if they averaged 15 keep that to the team score?

Starting XI
480
·
4.1K
·
over 14 years

Norwich 0 - 2 Leicester

Pukki, Cantwell

Bournemouth 0 - 2 Chelsea

Willian, Pulisic

Watford 1 - 3 Liverpool

Mane, Salah

Everton 2 - 2 ManU

Rashford, Martial

Marquee
1.7K
·
8.1K
·
over 16 years

20 Legend wrote:

On players leaving: neither situation is fair. If there was money riding on it, I'd say the players that have left should all be given 0s for the rest of the season. Given the team part is a "fun" event, then remove the players who said they cannot play.

Compltely agree with this, I've only flagged it as I'm aware my non contributions don't just ensure I finish bottom but it drags the teams thing down.

Starting XI
850
·
2.7K
·
almost 10 years

Norwich 1 - 3 Leicester

Pukki, Cantwell

Bournemouth 2 - 2 Chelsea

Willian, Pulisic

Watford 0 - 4 Liverpool

Ox, Salah

Everton 2 - 1 ManU

James, Martial

Legend
8.2K
·
15K
·
over 16 years

Norwich 2-2 Leicester

Pukki, Cantwell

Bournemouth 0 - 2 Chelsea

Willian, Pulisic

Watford 0 - 2 Liverpool

Ox, Salah

Everton 2 - 1 ManU

James, Martial

happy with whatever decision is made and agree that no matter what you decide its probably going to be "unfair" on ne group or another. I like the idea (if possible) of taking the average score of those who cannot make it any more and using that going forward until the end of for them. This should remove any unfair advantage to any team.

Marquee
3.2K
·
6.7K
·
over 16 years

Norwich 0 - 3 Leicester

Cantwell, Aarons

Bournemouth 0 - 2 Chelsea

Giroud, Gorghino

Watford 1 - 2 Liverpool

Salah, TAA

Everton 2 - 0 ManU

Wan bissaka, Fernades

Budgie lover
620
·
2.2K
·
almost 17 years

Norwich 1 - 0 Leicester

Pukki, Krul

Bournemouth 0 - 2 Chelsea

Tammy, Dave

Watford 1 - 2 Liverpool

Firmino, Salah

Everton 1 - 1 ManU

Martial, Wan-Bissaka

Phoenix Academy
88
·
200
·
over 16 years

Norwich 1 vs  2 Leicester

Pukki, Cantwell

Bournemouth 1 vs 3 Chelsea

Giroud, Barkley

Watford 0 vs 2 Liverpool

Mane, Ox

Everton 1 vs 1 ManU

Martial. Fernandes

Trialist
3
·
33
·
over 4 years

norwich 2 - Leicester 1

Pukki

Buendia 

Chelsea 2 - Bournemouth 1

Mount 

Willian

Liverpool 3 - watford 1

Mane

Salah

ManU 2 - everton 1

Ighalo

Fernandes

Starting XI
2.2K
·
4.3K
·
over 11 years

Norwich 0 vs 2 Leicester

Pukki, Cantwell

Bournemouth 0 vs 2 Chelsea

Giroud, Mount

Watford 0 vs 3 Liverpool

Mane, Salaj

Everton 1 vs 1 ManU

Martial. Greenwood

Edit: oops didn't realise the Norwich game already happened.

tradition and history
1.5K
·
9.9K
·
almost 17 years

Norwich  0- 2 Leicester

Pukki Cantwell

Bournemouth 0- 2 Chelsea

                          Mount Giroud

Watford  1- 2 Liverpool

                     Mane Salah

Everton  2- 1 Man Utd

                     James Ighalo

Legend
3.6K
·
15K
·
almost 17 years

damn forgot to pick myself this round, hilarious!

Marquee
300
·
5K
·
about 17 years

paulm wrote:

damn forgot to pick myself this round, hilarious!

Can you still do picks for Everton v Man Utd?

Legend
3.6K
·
15K
·
almost 17 years

Just noticed that!

Everton 2 ManU 1

Fernandez, Maguire

Legend
3.6K
·
15K
·
almost 17 years

Round 28 available points:

Norwich 1 Leicester 0

Pick Norwich to score 1 goal: 2 points

Pick Leicester to score 0 goals: 2 points

Pick margin Norwich +1: 3 points

Player points available:

Lewis 6 (MOM, goal, clean sheet), Aarons 3 (assist, clean sheet), Godfrey 2 (clean sheet), Hanley 2 (clean sheet), Krul 2 (clean sheet)

https://www.whoscored.com/Matches/1376217/Live/England-Premier-League-2019-2020-Norwich-Leicester

Bournemouth 2 Chelsea 2

Pick Bournemouth to score 2 goals: 2 points

Pick Chelsea to score 2 goals: 2 points

Pick margin 0: 3 points

Player points available:

Alonso 5 (MOM, 2 goals)

https://www.whoscored.com/Matches/1376207/Live/England-Premier-League-2019-2020-Bournemouth-Chelsea

Watford 3 Liverpool 0

Pick Watford to score 3 goals: 2 points

Pick Liverpool to score 0 goals: 2 points

Pick margin Watford +3: 3 points

Player points available:

Lovren 3 (=MOM), Lallana 3 (=MOM)

https://www.whoscored.com/Matches/1376221/Live/England-Premier-League-2019-2020-Watford-Liverpool

Everton 1 ManU 1

Pick Everton to score 1 goal: 2 points

Pick ManU to score 1 goal: 2 points

Pick margin 0: 3 points

Player points available:

Fernandes 4 (MOM, goal), Matic 1 (assist)

https://www.whoscored.com/Matches/1376211/Live/England-Premier-League-2019-2020-Everton-Manchester-United

Legend
3.6K
·
15K
·
almost 17 years

Ok looks like we have 3 options to resolve this situation:

1) Leave it

2) Remove the 3 who have dropped out from the records entirely, resulting in large bumps for ManU and Arsenal Teams in the standings

3) Work out the average for each at the point they dropped out, and apply that to the remaining weeks

To me, Option 3 is a pretty good idea, and seems to have some support in the comments above.

Any objections to going down that path?

FYI, I will post the latest results as is, to give myself a little time to tidy it all up. I'll aim to have it updated and accurate for when I post the Round 29 results (this sentence is mainly for Leggy, so he can chase me up if/when I don't deliver on it :)

Legend
3.6K
·
15K
·
almost 17 years

Individual standings after Round 28:

Team standings after Round 28:

Special mention goes to Libertynz for correctly calling Norwich to beat Leicester 1-0. Fantastic pick that!

Legend
8.2K
·
15K
·
over 16 years

geez that was a tough week for most. Only four scores above 10.

Starting XI
2.2K
·
4.3K
·
over 11 years

Liverpool 2-0 Bournemouth

Salah, Mane

Arsenal 2-1 West Ham

Auba, Nketiah

Sheffield Utd 2-1 Norwich

Cantwell, Pukki

Chelsea 2-1 Everton

William, Mount

Man Utd 1-2Man City

Fernandes, Greenwood

Legend
3.6K
·
15K
·
almost 17 years

THIS WEEKEND

Round 29 (Mar 8/9)

Liverpool vs Bournemouth

Pick FT score + 2 Liverpool players

Arsenal vs Westham

Pick FT score + 2 Arsenal players

Sheffield vs Norwich

Pick FT score + 2 Norwich players

Chelsea vs Everton

Pick FT score + 2 Chelsea players

ManU vs ManC

Pick FT score + 2 ManU players

Also, FYI, I am not going to get the updated situation ready in time for this round, to apply the average scores for those who have pulled out, as discussed. I've arranged to sit with Ronniemac mid next-week to update our spreadsheet, so hopefully that will be sorted by the end of Round 30.

Legend
3.6K
·
15K
·
almost 17 years

My picks

Round 29

Liverpool 2 Bournemouth 1

Salah, Alexander-Arnold

Arsenal 4 Westham 1

Pepe, Aubameyang

Sheffield 2 Norwich 1

Buendia, Pukki

Chelsea 2 Everton 2

Mount, Giroud

ManU 1 ManC 2

Fernandes, Martial

Legend
8.2K
·
15K
·
over 16 years

Round 29:

Liverpool 3-0 Bournemouth

Salah, Mane

Arsenal 2-1 West Ham

Auba, Nketiah

Sheffield Utd 1-1 Norwich

Cantwell, Pukki

Chelsea 2-1 Everton

William, Mount

Man Utd 0-2Man City

Fernandes, Greenwood

Starting XI
850
·
2.7K
·
almost 10 years

Round 29

Liverpool 4 Bournemouth 2

Salah, Firmino

Arsenal 4 West Ham 1

Pepe, Auba

Sheffield 2 Norwich 1

Pukki, Cantwell

Chelsea 2 Everton 1

Giroud, William

ManU 2 ManC 1

Fernandes, Greenwood

Legend
3.6K
·
15K
·
almost 17 years

Ronniemacs picks

Round 29 (Mar 8/9)

Liverpool 4 vs 0 Bournemouth – Time to bounce back!

Mane, Salah

Arsenal 2 vs 1 Westham

Saka, Auba

Sheffield 1 vs 1 Norwich

Duda, Pukki

Chelsea 2 vs 0 Everton

Pedro, Willian

ManU 2 vs 2 ManC – exciting draw with no winners to help Liverpool cement the league

Fernandes, Martial

Marquee
3.2K
·
6.7K
·
over 16 years

Round 29

Liverpool 2 Bournemouth 0

Salah, Mane

Arsenal 4 West Ham 2

Saka, Auba

Sheffield 1 Norwich 1

Pukki, Buendia

Chelsea 2 Everton 2

Alonso, Giroud

ManU 1 ManC 2

Fernandes, Martial

tradition and history
1.5K
·
9.9K
·
almost 17 years

Liverpool  3-0 Bournemouth

Salah Mane

Arsenal  2- 2 West Ham

Auba Laca

Sheffield Utd  2-0 Norwich

                            Pukki Cantwell

Chlsea  2- 0 Everton

Mount Giroud

Man Utd 1- 2 Man City

Martial Fernandes 

                        

Budgie lover
620
·
2.2K
·
almost 17 years

Round 29

Liverpool 2 Bournemouth 0

Salah, robertson

Arsenal 2 Westham 0

Pepe, Aubameyang

Sheffield 0 Norwich 1

Hanley, Pukki

Chelsea 1 Everton 1

William, Barkley

ManU 1 ManC 3

Fernandes, Martial

Starting XI
480
·
4.1K
·
over 14 years

Round 29 (Mar 8/9)

Liverpool 2 vs 0 Bournemouth 

Mane, Salah

Arsenal 2 vs 2 Westham

Saka, Auba

Sheffield 3 vs 2 Norwich

Cantwell, Pukki

Chelsea 2 vs 0 Everton

Abraham , Willian

ManU 0 vs 2 ManC

James martial

Starting XI
6.8K
·
4.6K
·
over 9 years

Shark I've been poor in getting on here lately ? 

Round 29 (Mar 8/9)

Liverpool 4 - 0 Bournemouth

Mane, Firmino

Arsenal 2 - 1  West Ham

Aubameyang, Saka

Sheffield 2 - 0 Norwich

Cantwell, Pukki

Chelsea 1 - 1 Everton

Mount, Abraham

Manchester United 2 - 1 Manchester City

Martial, McTominay

Starting XI
99
·
3.7K
·
over 14 years

Liverpool 2-0 Bournemouth 

Salah, Firmino

Arsenal 2-0 West Ham

Auba, Pepe 

Sheffield United 1-1 Norwich 

Buendia, Cantwell

Chelsea 1-0 Everton

Giroud, Azpilicueta

Manchester United 1-1 Manchester City

Fernandez, maguire

Trialist
3
·
33
·
over 4 years

Norwich 2 - sheff united 1

Pukki

McLean

Liverpool 3 - Bournemouth 0

Salah

Alexander- Arnold

Arsenal 2 - west ham 0

Auba

Pepe

Chelsea 3 - everton 1

Mount 

Willian

Man city 2 - ManU 1

Martial

Fernandes 

Legend
3.6K
·
15K
·
almost 17 years

hey lads, im away for work at the mo and without my spreadsheets, so will update scores later this week. 

Fyi, the man city vs arsenal make up game is not in our picks round, so no picks needed for that. 

Legend
3.6K
·
15K
·
almost 17 years

THIS WEEKEND:

Round 30 (Mar 15/16/17)

Brighton vs Arsenal

Pick FT score + 2 Arsenal players

Norwich vs Southampton

Pick FT score + 2 Norwich players

Aston Villa vs Chelsea

Pick FT score + 2 Chelsea players

Tottenham vs ManU

Pick FT score + 2 ManU players

Everton vs Liverpool

Pick FT score + 2 Liverpool players

Marquee
3.2K
·
6.7K
·
over 16 years

Are we doing the Man City v Arsenal game mid week?
If so my picks are:

Man City 1 Arsenal 1

Saka, Laca

tradition and history
1.5K
·
9.9K
·
almost 17 years

kwlap wrote:

Are we doing the Man City v Arsenal game mid week?
If so my picks are:

Man City 1 Arsenal 1

Saka, Laca

If you look 2 posts up you will have your answer.

Starting XI
480
·
4.1K
·
over 14 years

Brighton 1vs3Arsenal

Laca and Auba

Norwich 1vs1 Southampton

Cantwell, Pukki

Aston Villa 0vs3 Chelsea

Mount , Willian

Tottenham 2vs2 ManU

Martial, James

Everton 1vs1 Liverpool

Salah Mane

Starting XI
850
·
2.7K
·
almost 10 years

Brighton 0 vs 2 Arsenal

Pepe, Auba

Norwich 1 vs 1 Southampton

Cantwell, Buendia

Aston Villa 0 vs 3 Chelsea

Mount, Giroud

Tottenham 2 vs 1 ManU

Martial, Fernandez

Everton 1 vs 3 Liverpool

Mane, Milner

Legend
3.6K
·
15K
·
almost 17 years

Round 29 available points:

Liverpool 2 Bournemouth 1

Pick Liverpool to score 2 goals: 2 points

Pick Bournemouth to score 1 goal: 2 points

Pick margin Liverpool +1: 3 points

Player points available:

Mane 5 (MOM, goal, assist), Salah 1 (goal), van Dijk 1 (assist)

https://www.whoscored.com/Matches/1376241/Live/England-Premier-League-2019-2020-Liverpool-Bournemouth

Arsenal 1 Westham 0

Pick Arsenal to score 1 goal: 2 points

Pick Westham to score 0 goals: 2 points

Pick margin Arsenal +1: 3 points

Player points available:

Leno 5 (MOM, clean sheet), Saka 2 (clean sheet), Luiz 2 (clean sheet), Mari 2 (clean sheet), Sokratis 2 (clean sheet), Bellerin 2 (clean sheet), Lacazette 1 (goal), Ozil 1 (assist)

https://www.whoscored.com/Matches/1376226/Live/England-Premier-League-2019-2020-Arsenal-West-Ham

Sheffield 1 Norwich 0

Pick Sheffield to score 1 goal: 2 points

Pick Norwich to score 0 goals: 2 points

Pick margin Sheffield +1: 3 points

Player points available:

McLean 3 (MOM)

https://www.whoscored.com/Matches/1376247/Live/England-Premier-League-2019-2020-Sheffield-United-Norwich

Chelsea 4 Everton 0

Pick Chelsea to score 4 goals: 2 points

Pick Everton to score 0 goals: 2 points

Pick margin Chelsea +4: 3 points

Player points available:

Barkley 5 (MOM, 2 assists), Willian 2 (goal, assist), Pedro 2 (goal, assist), Alonso 2 (clean sheet), Rudiger 2 (clean sheet), Azpuilicueta 2 (clean sheet), Zouma 2 (clean sheet), Kepa 2 (clean sheet), Giroud 1 (goal), Mount 1 (goal)

https://www.whoscored.com/Matches/1376232/Live/England-Premier-League-2019-2020-Chelsea-Everton

ManU 2 Man City 0

Pick ManU to score 2 goals: 2 points

Pick Man City to score 0 goals: 2 points

Pick margin ManU +2: 3 points

Player points available:

Wan-bissaka 5 (MOM, clean sheet), Williams 2 (clean sheet), Maguire 2 (clean sheet), Lindelof 2 (clean sheet), Shaw 2 (clean sheet), de Gea 2 (clean sheet), Martial 1 (goal), McTominay 1 (goal), Fernandes 1 (assist)

https://www.whoscored.com/Matches/1376244/Live/England-Premier-League-2019-2020-Manchester-United-Manchester-City

You’ll need an account to join the conversation!

Sign in Sign up