Large kwblarge

Southern Football (incl Southern United)

The JourneyFan
Starting XI
FilledFilledFilledEmptyEmpty
For post img 1193

Gunners wrote:

I see Lewis Wall scored for Mosgiel in the cup on the weekend, is this right? He was playing for GI 2 weeks ago. WHats the rules around eligibility nowadays? I thought you needed to play two games before you were allowed to play in the cup. I think Mosgiel could be in trouble. 

no its changed,  you just need to be registered for 10 days now

No way he could have been registered for 10 business days before playing in that game though? West End should appeal!

don't think the regs stipulate business days just days

http://thejourneyfan.blogspot.co.nz/

New Zealand Football Media Association Website of the year 2015 & 2016

sawu
Phoenix Academy
FilledFilledEmptyEmptyEmpty
For post 1409920686 1985 1986 rufer s

If it matters - I don't think Lewis played in Cup round 1, so he wouldn't have been cup tied?

As cultured as Che Bunce's left foot and as profilic as John Lammers

FSobservation
Trialist
FilledEmptyEmptyEmptyEmpty
For post default

Gunners wrote:

I see Lewis Wall scored for Mosgiel in the cup on the weekend, is this right? He was playing for GI 2 weeks ago. WHats the rules around eligibility nowadays? I thought you needed to play two games before you were allowed to play in the cup. I think Mosgiel could be in trouble. 

no its changed,  you just need to be registered for 10 days now

No way he could have been registered for 10 business days before playing in that game though? West End should appeal!

don't think the regs stipulate business days just days

Chatham Cup Regulations, 7.4.1

"In all matches of this competition, each player, except where he has played for his club during the previous season and has not played in any match for any other club in New Zealand during the current season, must have been registered with his club for ten business days prior to the playing of any match in the competition." 

In non-legalese - Mosgiel should be out of the competition

Gunners
Trialist
FilledEmptyEmptyEmptyEmpty
For post default

Gunners wrote:

I see Lewis Wall scored for Mosgiel in the cup on the weekend, is this right? He was playing for GI 2 weeks ago. WHats the rules around eligibility nowadays? I thought you needed to play two games before you were allowed to play in the cup. I think Mosgiel could be in trouble. 

no its changed,  you just need to be registered for 10 days now

No way he could have been registered for 10 business days before playing in that game though? West End should appeal!

don't think the regs stipulate business days just days

Chatham Cup Regulations, 7.4.1

"In all matches of this competition, each player, except where he has played for his club during the previous season and has not played in any match for any other club in New Zealand during the current season, must have been registered with his club for ten business days prior to the playing of any match in the competition." 

In non-legalese - Mosgiel should be out of the competition

Does West end need to complain? Surely it must happen automatically? It was only 9 days after the transfer unitl he played by my calculations. This is terrible organisation from the club. I heard they had really hoped to go all the way this year. 

sawu
Phoenix Academy
FilledFilledEmptyEmptyEmpty
For post 1409920686 1985 1986 rufer s

According to Comet he transferred 10 calendar days prior (although not 10 business days)...

As cultured as Che Bunce's left foot and as profilic as John Lammers

Gunners
Trialist
FilledEmptyEmptyEmptyEmpty
For post default
FSobservation
Trialist
FilledEmptyEmptyEmptyEmpty
For post default

I someone going to message the West End AFC Facebook page? This ineligible player scored against them and irrespective of the fact Mosgiel are a better side, they should not be allowed to continue in the competition. Horrible blunder yes, but all sides should have an equal chance - that's why rules and regulations are there!

I do hope West End know about this, I would like to see them try and write some new history! Maybe they've ever made it this far at all!

Gunners
Trialist
FilledEmptyEmptyEmptyEmpty
For post default

I someone going to message the West End AFC Facebook page? This ineligible player scored against them and irrespective of the fact Mosgiel are a better side, they should not be allowed to continue in the competition. Horrible blunder yes, but all sides should have an equal chance - that's why rules and regulations are there!

I do hope West End know about this, I would like to see them try and write some new history! Maybe they've ever made it this far at all!

If anyone know's the coach then let me know their number and ill call personally. There's no place for cheating in this prestigious cup competition. 

Noel 76'
Trialist
FilledEmptyEmptyEmptyEmpty
For post default

can’t you just tell nz football if the life and death of the comp is at stake.

Gunners
Trialist
FilledEmptyEmptyEmptyEmpty
For post default

Noel 76' wrote:

can’t you just tell nz football if the life and death of the comp is at stake.

The phrase "snitches get stitches" implies that anyone who is a snitch would get physically beaten up. A snitch is someone who publicly gives personal information of other people without their consent. The phrase "snitches get stitches" implies that anyone who is a snitch would get physically beaten up. Similar words.

FSobservation
Trialist
FilledEmptyEmptyEmptyEmpty
For post default

Gunners wrote:

I someone going to message the West End AFC Facebook page? This ineligible player scored against them and irrespective of the fact Mosgiel are a better side, they should not be allowed to continue in the competition. Horrible blunder yes, but all sides should have an equal chance - that's why rules and regulations are there!

I do hope West End know about this, I would like to see them try and write some new history! Maybe they've ever made it this far at all!

If anyone know's the coach then let me know their number and ill call personally. There's no place for cheating in this prestigious cup competition. 

No idea of the number, but this is the facebook page https://www.facebook.com/westendafc/- they receive messages directly. I think Football South deals with this as well, not NZ Football - i'm sure you could call Garbhan Coughlan who is the competitions manager

Therealslim
Trialist
FilledEmptyEmptyEmptyEmpty
For post default

Sounds like some horse heads dont want to play the plainsmen.

Gunners
Trialist
FilledEmptyEmptyEmptyEmpty
For post default

Therealslim wrote:

Sounds like some horse heads dont want to play the plainsmen.

More like its cheating

Therealslim
Trialist
FilledEmptyEmptyEmptyEmpty
For post default

would never have affected the result, but to be fair that Timaru side were better than the bottom three in Dunedin Leauge.

FSobservation
Trialist
FilledEmptyEmptyEmptyEmpty
For post default

Therealslim wrote:

would never have affected the result, but to be fair that Timaru side were better than the bottom three in Dunedin Leauge.

That's not really the point though, is it. If you keep within the rules and regulations, then there is no problem. 

Gunners
Trialist
FilledEmptyEmptyEmptyEmpty
For post default

Therealslim wrote:

would never have affected the result, but to be fair that Timaru side were better than the bottom three in Dunedin Leauge.

That's not really the point though, is it. If you keep within the rules and regulations, then there is no problem. 

Exactly

Therealslim
Trialist
FilledEmptyEmptyEmptyEmpty
For post default

Gunners wrote:

Therealslim wrote:

Sounds like some horse heads dont want to play the plainsmen.

More like its cheating

I wouldnt want to play them either.

FSobservation
Trialist
FilledEmptyEmptyEmptyEmpty
For post default

Therealslim wrote:

Gunners wrote:

Therealslim wrote:

Sounds like some horse heads dont want to play the plainsmen.

More like its cheating

I wouldnt want to play them either.

Well judging by your need to cheat, you can't be that good of a team. Not brilliant at taking responsibility either by the looks of it.

Therealslim
Trialist
FilledEmptyEmptyEmptyEmpty
For post default

Therealslim wrote:

Gunners wrote:

Therealslim wrote:

Sounds like some horse heads dont want to play the plainsmen.

More like its cheating

I wouldnt want to play them either.

Well judging by your need to cheat, you can't be that good of a team. Not brilliant at taking responsibility either by the looks of it.

What a joke, Need to cheat? obviously the best team in Dunedin was going to struggle against such an opposing team, get your head out of the clouds buddy. 

FSobservation
Trialist
FilledEmptyEmptyEmptyEmpty
For post default

Therealslim wrote:

Therealslim wrote:

Gunners wrote:

Therealslim wrote:

Sounds like some horse heads dont want to play the plainsmen.

More like its cheating

I wouldnt want to play them either.

Well judging by your need to cheat, you can't be that good of a team. Not brilliant at taking responsibility either by the looks of it.

What a joke, Need to cheat? obviously the best team in Dunedin was going to struggle against such an opposing team, get your head out of the clouds buddy. 

Why did you cheat then? 

Post New Reply

Please Login or Create an account to post a reply.